Ginger Snap Crafts: label review {the results}

label review {the results}

Today I’m over at So You Think Your Crafty sharing some items from my etsy shop, Ginger Snaps (annnd sharing a coupon code!!!), & later on this week I’ll be back with a tutorial on how to make one of the items in my shop.  So make sure you stop by & say hi. :)

Speaking of etsy shops….remember my guinea pig post???  :)

For the past year I have been selling washable personalized sippy cups & drink cup labels in my etsy shop.  Well, the dreaded thing happened…one of my customers emailed me & said all of her labels had fallen off!  If you know me I was a little FrEaKeD out by that!  She was super nice, and I sent her a new set of cups and some extra labels.  Thank you, nice customer! :)  I heart you!  Buuuut I felt so bad.  I have used these same labels on our cups forever, & I’ve never have had a problem.  FYI: I cut these labels with a different kind of vinyl.  It’s called cast vinyl (ORACAL 751 High Performance Cast Vinyl), and it’s suppose to be pretty heavy duty.

I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE cast vinyl…I blogged about it here and here and here

So I came up with the idea to do a little product testing of my own just to see how the labels would perform in other people’s dishwashers (in comes my guinea pig post). :) I sent of set of 3 labels to my reviewers to apply to their own cups.  My little labels went BIG places: Washington, Tennessee, Illinois, Minnesota, Nevada, Ohio, even out of the country to Ontario, Canada ANNND even across the ocean to North Yorkshire (in the United Kingdom!!). I really had a lot of fun with this! I LOVED getting to know some of YOU better!!! You guys are awesome & so fun to work with!!!  Thank YOU!

cast vinyl review results

So here they are - the results! :)

I applied two of these beauties onto my sons plastic sippy cups! They survived every test I put them through wonderfully! Unfortunately, my nephew began to pick off one of the letters! The dishwasher test was very successful though! No matter how many times I scrubbed them, they went through the ancient dishwasher or got abused by my son, they held up so strong! I even boiled the cup with them on to sanitize from a sickness and again....flawless! Definitely a purchase in the future!

The labels are great.  For the first time it kept my boys from arguing who's water bottle was who's.

They were put on travel mugs (for hot drinks). The ones that I followed your instructions I had no issues. The other one that I didn't follow 100% started to come off a bit but when I took it out of the dishwasher right away I just held the parts that were starting to peel ever so slightly and everything was fine.

I loved, loved, loved the vinyl. I even bought new glasses to put them on! They looked awesome!!!!! Sadly, during the 3rd wash (in the dishwasher), the vinyl came off (of all 3). I wish I had better news...but they looked amazing!

All three of my kids, (my fourteen year old included!) thought they were the greatest thing and used the bottles that we put them on on a daily basis.  You asked what I put the labels on-- believe it or not I put them on recycled Starbuck's Frappuccino bottles. They were super easy to apply, held up great in both the dishwasher and the sink (quite often I had to hand wash them) and even held up to my three year old "picking" at the label.  Overall the "personalized" bottles were a hit and my kids thought I was the coolest mom for making them. :D

They are awesome, but maybe you should include a warning in your labels about how addictive they are! I keep thinking of things around my house I could label! :) (my kids maybe?!)

Loved the font you used very nice, easy to apply, holding up very well, would love to see them in colors too if possible.

On the glass I did first, all the letters peeled off and got all mashed up the first time I dish washed it.  I am willing to take all the blame, because I got impatient about waiting like your instructions said, and I peeled off the backing before the 15 minutes was up.  The other two had not been used yet, so after the first one was destroyed, I went back over the other two with a piece of waxed paper and a credit card in hopes of sticking the vinyl down better.  These two have held up great after nearly daily use the last couple of weeks.  (FYI, my dishwasher is a dinosaur - probably 20+ years old - just so you know what the labels were up against.)

Mary's birthday 062

Here’s a picture from one of the “reviewers”! :)

So overall, not too bad.  Pretty good reviews! :)  Annnd YES I’m still a HUGE fan of cast vinyl. 

For Christmas I made these adorable popcorn bowls for gifts for family gifts. 


For the nursery class at our church I made these sippy cups!  A HUGE hit!  (Took these pictures after they had been used and washed a few times in our dishwasher.)


Buuuuut since now I can’t say 100% of the time they’ll be OK I’ve decided to stop carrying the cast vinyl labels in my etsy shop.  Three of the reviewers did have issues with their labels. One even had one come off & another all 3 came off the third time they got washed in the dishwasher. :( I’m not sure if it’s how you apply them or if it could be what kind of dishwasher or soap you use that could make a difference.  I’m stumped!  So I’d rather be safe than sorry when it comes to paying customers.  :)

Thank YOU again to all of my reviewers!!!


  1. Maybe it's the not leaving them on before pealing off the transfer tape? I had a hard time waiting as I really wanted to see them! :) But mine are still great and go in the dishwasher on either shelf without any signs of wear. Can't think what the problem could be!

    And I love that I'm "all the way from the UK!" makes me feel very special out here in the wet and cold!

    It was an awesome opportunity.

  2. I have got to get some of this vinyl! Names on sippy cups would be so nice around here. :)

  3. That is a hard one! I'm sorry to hear they didn't pass the test on all ends. The hard things is that even products you buy from the store don't hold up but I completely understand wanting your customers to be happy!

  4. I saw these in your etsy shop, and made my own. I used indoor/outdoor vinyl from Vinyl Expressions online, and have washed them on the top rack with the hottest setting at least 20 times, and they are perfect! I think they are adorable, and my kids adore them...maybe you just need different vinyl? Good luck!

    Jessica @ Mom 4 Real

  5. As you know I was one of your "reviewer"...and I just want you to know I am still using them to this day and they are holing up fine!!

  6. Bummer three people had trouble with theirs and bummer that you won't be carrying them in your shop. :(

    My kids are STILL loving their personalized Starbuck's bottles-- I was hoping to be able to buy more of their names to use as backups if a bottle should happen to break. Or wear out!

    I totally understand your decision. Just bummed. :(



Thank you so much stopping by Ginger Snap Crafts. I am so glad YOU are here. I so appreciate you being here & especially for your comments. They really make my day! :) If you have a question please leave it here, and I'll answer it in the comments. You can also email me at ginger at gingersnapcrafts dot com. For a quicker response feel free to message me on facebook. Hope to see you again soon! :)